How to Choose a Mascara for Your Lashes: Brushes, Formulas and Tips

A makeup artist's guide to choosing mascara: which brush shape suits your lashes, waterproof vs. tubing vs. regular formulas, and how to apply it without clumps.

Mascara is the product people buy most often and think about least. Most choose based on the packaging promise («volume», «length», «lift») and then wonder why their lashes look spiky, clumpy or smudged. In my kit, I carry several mascaras because different lashes need different brushes and formulas. Once you know what your lashes need, choosing a mascara becomes easy, and the result is dramatically better.

Start with your lashes

Look at your natural lashes in a mirror, in good light. Ask yourself:

  • Are they short or long?
  • Are they sparse or dense?
  • Are they straight, curled or pointing down?
  • Are they fine and soft, or thick and coarse?
  • Do they touch your brow bone or lids when you blink? (Common with hooded eyes.)

Your answers decide the brush and the formula.

Brush shapes explained

Brush What it does Best for
Large, full bristle brush Deposits a lot of product for volume Sparse lashes needing volume
Thin, slim brush Reaches tiny lashes, separates and lengthens Short lashes, inner corners, lower lashes
Curved brush Follows the eye’s shape and lifts Straight lashes, round eyes
Comb (plastic bristles) Separates, defines and lengthens Dense lashes prone to clumping
Ball tip or spiked tip Precise application at corners Inner corners, lower lashes
Hourglass shape Volume in the center, precision at the ends All-round use
Artist tip Natural fiber or soft nylon bristles hold more product and give volume; plastic or silicone bristles separate lashes and give definition. If you hate clumps, try a silicone brush.

Formulas explained

Regular (washable) mascara

Easy to apply and to remove. Great for everyday wear if your lashes hold a curl and you don’t have oily lids. Can smudge on hooded or oily lids and in humidity.

Waterproof mascara

Resists water, tears and humidity, and holds a curl best. Ideal for weddings, the beach, emotional days and straight lashes. The downside: it’s harder to remove and can be drying if worn every day. Always use an oil-based remover.

Tubing mascara

Instead of painting the lashes, it forms tiny «tubes» around each lash. It doesn’t smudge or flake, and it slides off with warm water and gentle pressure. My favorite for hooded eyes, oily lids, sensitive eyes and people who get «raccoon eyes». It gives definition and length more than dramatic volume.

Lengthening, volumizing, lifting

These are effects created by the combination of brush and formula. Lengthening formulas often contain fibers; volumizing formulas are thicker; lifting formulas are designed to hold a curl.

Matching mascara to your lashes

  • Short lashes: a slim brush and a lengthening, tubing or fiber formula. Wiggle from the root.
  • Sparse lashes: a full brush and a volumizing formula; build in two thin coats.
  • Straight or downward lashes: curl first, then a waterproof or lifting formula with a curved brush.
  • Long, dense lashes: a comb or silicone brush to separate and define, avoiding very thick formulas.
  • Hooded eyes or oily lids: a tubing or waterproof formula to prevent transfer. See makeup tips for hooded eyes.
  • Sensitive eyes or contact lenses: a tubing formula, fragrance-free, labeled ophthalmologist-tested; avoid fiber formulas, which can flake into the eye.

How to apply mascara like an artist

  1. Curl first: place the curler at the base of the lashes, squeeze gently for five seconds, then move halfway up and squeeze again for a natural curve. Never curl after mascara.
  2. Wipe the wand: remove excess product on the edge of the tube. Too much product causes clumps.
  3. Start at the root: place the brush at the base of the lashes and wiggle side to side, then pull up and out.
  4. Angle the brush: for the outer lashes, tilt the wand toward the temple to lift and elongate; for the inner corner, use the tip of the wand vertically.
  5. Second coat while wet: apply a second coat before the first dries to avoid clumps.
  6. Lower lashes: hold the wand vertically and use the tip, lightly, or skip them for a more open-eye look.
  7. Separate: a clean spoolie or lash comb separates any clumps.

Color: black, brown or colored?

  • Black: maximum definition, perfect for dark hair and evening looks.
  • Brown or brown-black: softer, natural, ideal for fair skin, blonde or red hair, and no-makeup looks.
  • Navy: makes the whites of the eyes look brighter; lovely on brown eyes.
  • Burgundy or plum: enhances green and hazel eyes.

Mascara hygiene and when to replace it

Mascara is the makeup product with the shortest life. Most experts recommend replacing it about every three months, because the tube and wand can harbor bacteria. Replace it immediately after an eye infection. Never share mascara, don’t add water or saliva to a drying tube, and don’t «pump» the wand in and out, which pushes air into the tube and dries the formula. Track your opening dates with the makeup expiration tracker.

Troubleshooting

Problem Fix
Clumps Wipe the wand, apply in thin coats, comb through while wet
Smudges under the eyes Tubing or waterproof formula; set under-eye concealer with powder
Lashes lose curl Waterproof formula; heat the curler briefly with a hairdryer (test on your hand)
Flaking Old mascara or fiber formula; replace it
Spider lashes Too many coats of a dried formula; use one wet coat

Removing mascara gently

Hold a cotton pad soaked in an oil-based remover against your closed eyes for twenty seconds, then wipe downward and outward. For tubing mascara, warm water and gentle pressure with your fingertips slide the tubes off. Never rub hard; it weakens lashes over time.

Mascara and lash curlers: getting the curl to last

A curl that drops after an hour is one of the most common complaints I hear. The lash curler and the mascara work together. Choose a curler that fits the curve of your eyelid; if it pinches the corners or misses the outer lashes, it’s the wrong shape. Replace the rubber pad when it gets a groove. Curl in two or three gentle presses along the lash instead of one hard squeeze, which creates an unnatural «L» bend. Then apply a waterproof or lifting formula immediately, from the very root. If your lashes are very straight, a primer or a waterproof top coat over regular mascara helps hold the shape.

Lash primers, serums and tints

Lash primers are usually white or clear and go on before mascara to add thickness and help hold curl. They’re useful for sparse lashes, but let them dry slightly, and make sure the mascara covers all the white. Lash serums are marketed for conditioning or growth; results vary by product and person, and some serums may cause irritation or changes in eyelid color, so read the label carefully and stop if your eyes react. Lash tints and lifts, done professionally, give color and curl for several weeks, which is wonderful if you’d rather skip mascara on a daily basis.

Mascara for different occasions

  • Everyday: a tubing or regular lengthening formula, one or two coats.
  • Weddings and emotional days: waterproof, always. Read more in how to do your own wedding makeup.
  • Evenings: a volumizing formula, two coats, with extra on the outer lashes.
  • Gym, beach and summer: waterproof or tubing, or skip mascara and curl your lashes.
  • No-makeup look: a brown mascara, one coat, focused on the roots.

FAQs

How often should I replace my mascara?

About every three months, or immediately after an eye infection.

Is waterproof mascara bad for lashes?

Not if you remove it gently with an oil-based remover. Daily rubbing to remove it is what can cause lash loss. Many people alternate waterproof and regular mascara.

Can I layer two mascaras?

Yes. Artists often use a lengthening mascara first and a volumizing one on top, or a regular mascara topped with a waterproof one for curl.

Expensive vs. drugstore mascara?

Many drugstore mascaras perform excellently. It’s an area where you don’t need to spend much; brush and formula matter more than price.

Once you’ve found the right combination of brush and formula for your lashes, mascara becomes the one product that makes the biggest difference in the least time. To see it in a full routine, try my everyday makeup tutorial.

Bianca Añez
Bianca AñezMakeup & Hair Artist · Licensed Facial Specialist

Miami-based makeup and hair artist and licensed facial specialist with more than 10 years of experience, specializing in bridal and special-occasion beauty. More about Bianca →